Continue with Facebook
Continue with Email
When comparing a VFEX-listed property developer and a ZSE-listed REIT that enjoys tax exemptions, consider the following key aspects:
1. Business Model & Revenue Generation
- VFEX-listed property developer: Generates revenue from property sales, leasing, and development. Cash flows are often lumpy due to project-based earnings.
- ZSE-listed REIT: Earns rental income from a diversified real estate portfolio. Cash flows are generally more predictable and stable.
2. Taxation Impact
- VFEX Property Developer: Subject to corporate tax (24.72% in Zimbabwe) and other taxes on profits.
- ZSE REIT: Exempt from corporate income tax if it complies with regulatory distribution requirements (typically paying out at least 80% of its income as dividends).
Implication: A REIT's tax exemption allows it to distribute higher after-tax earnings to investors, whereas a developer's profits are reduced by taxation.
3. Dividend Yield & Returns
- Property Developer: Typically reinvests profits into new projects rather than paying high dividends.
- REIT: Designed to provide regular dividends to investors, making it attractive for income-seeking investors.
Implication: REITs usually offer higher and more consistent dividend yields compared to property developers.
4. Risk Profile
- Developer: Higher risk due to exposure to project delays, construction cost overruns, economic downturns, and demand fluctuations.
- REIT: Lower risk due to stable rental income, but still exposed to market cycles and tenant default risks.
5. Liquidity & Investor Attraction
- VFEX Developer: May have lower liquidity since VFEX generally has lower trading volumes.
- ZSE REIT: Higher liquidity and broader investor base due to its tax efficiency and income focus.
6. Valuation Metrics
- Developer: Valued using Price-to-Earnings (P/E), Net Asset Value (NAV) per share, and Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) models.
- REIT: Typically valued using Funds From Operations (FFO), Dividend Yield, and Net Asset Value (NAV) per unit.
Key Takeaway
A ZSE-listed REIT is generally a better option for income-focused investors due to its tax efficiency and stable dividends. A VFEX-listed property developer might appeal more to growth-oriented investors looking for capital appreciation but comes with higher risks.
